Scaling a DTC E-Commerce's Support During Hypergrowth Season
See how Horatio turned fulfillment bottlenecks into retention opportunities for a leading DTC personal care brand through automated reporting and proactive CX.

A high-growth direct-to-consumer personal care brand specializing in natural, high-performance grooming products for men, delivering an engaging, subscriber-first e-commerce experience to millions of customers nationwide.
The Challenge
During an early period of rapid, pandemic-driven demand, the company faced significant supply chain disruptions, resulting in severe fulfillment delays and shipping bottlenecks. This operational strain coincided with frequent website glitches, including broken links, faulty product pages, and redirection errors that complicated the checkout process.
As a result, customer contact volume spiked significantly with order status inquiries, product questions, and address modification requests. Complicating logistics further, courier restrictions on non-USPS carriers prevented successful deliveries to PO Boxes, generating a continuous wave of delivery failures. Because the client lacked a centralized internal knowledge base, frontline teams were unable to resolve these issues independently, forcing them to constantly escalate routine tickets back to the brand's internal team for resolution.
Horatio's Solution
Horatio introduced structured quality monitoring, data reporting, and proactive customer retention workflows to stabilize the support queue and streamline communication.
- Assigned a dedicated agent to conduct website quality assurance audits twice a week, proactively identifying bugs and navigation errors affecting the checkout experience.
- Established a specialized Slack escalation channel to track, document, and route complex product safety inquiries regarding natural ingredients and allergies.
- Developed automated Bad Address Reports and Unshipped Order Reports to systematically identify shipping errors and fulfillment bottlenecks before they led to major backlogs.
- Introduced structured customer retention strategies by implementing customized macros and concession playbooks, including gift cards, discounts, and store credits, to resolve supply chain friction.
- Built and deployed the brand’s first centralized internal knowledge base and customer support playbook using Notion to align the team on correct procedures.
Partnership Evolution
- Significantly increased support efficiency across the entire team by centralizing previously siloed information into an accessible repository.
- Established a distinct operational baseline through the custom playbook, continuously updated with real-time interaction data to build reliable internal processes.
- Fostered highly autonomous support associates capable of resolving complex cases independently without relying on constant internal escalation pathways.
- Strengthened the strategic partnership between Horatio and the client by successfully deploying stable, self-sufficient customer experience operations.


Why It Matters
Supply chain disruptions and technical website glitches pose a massive risk to customer trust when a DTC brand is scaling rapidly. Horatio helped the organization transition from a chaotic, manual escalation queue to a self-sufficient support operation anchored by a centralized knowledge base and structured workflows. Beyond simply relieving pressure on the internal team, this framework secured customer lifetime value and established a resilient customer experience model designed to safeguard brand loyalty during phases of massive expansion.
